After announcing their engagement in January, the couple surprised fans with even more exciting news only two weeks later: they were expecting! While confirming they would welcome a son, Sigler admitted she was even shocked by the timing of it all.
"We definitely thought it was going to be a slow relationship process and possibly an engagement — I felt like it was coming — so the baby definitely threw us for a loop," the actress said in April.
Despite denouncing heels for the remainder of her pregnancy, Sigler sported a pair for her June baby shower, where she told PEOPLE she and Dykstra were having trouble deciding on their son's name.
"We have a couple of [baby] names we're toying with. We'll call him one name one week and one name another week. I think we have our favorite, but you never know. We could change our minds when we meet him," she said at the time.