Whine? Not! Four Ways to Deal with Whining Children

We've got advice about teaching your preschooler to find less annoying ways to get what she wants.
  • Share
  • Print Print
  • Comment Comments (8)

I have to say, my daughter, Avery, is already somewhat of an overachiever. She always runs when she could walk, she routinely gobbles down her dinner so she can finish before everyone else at the table, and she insists on climbing higher than all the kids on the jungle gym (luckily, I have a strong stomach). But I'd be remiss not to include this less-than-desirable distinction: Avery is also a world-class whiner, griping at a jaw-dropping pitch for such lengths that she can easily outdo any other 4-year-old in a single squawk session.

Avery's impassioned approach to life is refreshing, but her overzealous whining? Not so much. Whether she's begging for a brownie or pining for a new pet, her tenacious requests try my nerves. However, my mind -- and my eardrums -- were put to rest by some expert reassurance: "Whining is totally normal," says Janeen Hayward, a licensed clinical professional counselor and founder of Swellbeing, a parenting resource in New York City. Virtually all kids become pros at the shrill mewling that serves as a desperate plea for something (usually an item they know they can't have) and yet also expresses a feeling of powerlessness that crying or talking doesn't. "Three- and 4-year- olds whine frequently because they have big expectations and desires, but don't always get their way or have the ability to do the task at hand," explains Hayward.

Sure, it's comforting to confirm that Avery is simply expressing her needs like the rest of her pals. But it's also frustrating to realize that such an annoying behavior is so incredibly effective. The second she begins howling, I usually fulfill her request no matter how outrageous it is (chocolate milk in bed!), simply to stop the noise and save my sanity. Of course, I'm only making the problem worse. "When you give in to your child's demands immediately, you're reinforcing her behavior," Hayward points out. Ready to wipe out the gripes? Use these tips to win the war on whining.

Next:  Step 1: React

 

What do you think of this story?  Tell Us.

Related Links
Two-year-olds act out their emotions in some prett...

The earlier your child learns how to do housework,...

While the celebration of your toddler's second bir...



Comments
Comments (8)
4725159334
mallabera wrote:

If a kid is getting louder take them out of the store. If a kid the age of 9 is throwing a tantrum... go to his/her school and do it in front of their friends... =) I promise that WILL have a response.. They don't like it? Funny because neither do you! I did this in front of my daughter's class and she has NEVER tried a tantrum again!

5/2/2012 12:55:31 AM Report Abuse
mallabera wrote:

Salgab-- I let my kids bring a small notebook and a pen to church. They are quiet, and they participate in Sunday School happily without dreading the "boring part"

5/2/2012 12:52:08 AM Report Abuse
salgadopatito wrote:

my baby sister does not like to go to church what cani do when i take her??

3/2/2012 02:48:46 PM Report Abuse
grants196040 wrote:

I don't agree with any of it. The word No will automatically triggers the whine box. Now matter how much I try to explain... the more I explain the louder he gets.. I just have learned to simply walk away... and that works great. Once he realized that I am not going to pay him any attention, his focus changes.

1/14/2012 09:21:33 PM Report Abuse
anonymous wrote:

Such great tips!!!! I especially like how stepping up the silliness is used to make your child feel more comfortable with listening to rules.

12/13/2011 11:24:06 AM Report Abuse
smccobb wrote:

I agree, what do you do with a whining, tantrum-throwing 9 year old? Help!

8/23/2011 03:46:28 PM Report Abuse
anonymous wrote:

What happens when the whining still goes on when the child is 8 years old?

2/22/2011 11:59:55 AM Report Abuse
jmc911991 wrote:

Totally agree with telling them that you can't understand them when they are whining. I tell my boys that when they can talk like big kids then I'll be able to listen and help. Usually works! www.myrealbirthstory.com

2/17/2011 07:01:12 PM Report Abuse
Add your comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Please confirm your comment by answering the question below and clicking "Submit Comment."

  • Mom Finds
  • Mom Tools
  • Win
Parents Magazine on Facebook

Latest updates from Parents Network

Follow American Baby on Twitter Follow Parents on Twitter