Crib Mattresses

A baby's first mattress should be firmer than one designed for an older child or adult. Whether you choose a foam or innerspring model, a crib mattress should fit snugly in the crib's frame and meet Consumer Product Safety Commission standards. When your child graduates to a real bed, you can purchase a softer mattress, but it should have the same water-resistant features as a crib mattress. When shopping for a crib mattress, fit is the most important factor. The mattress needs to fit snugly in the crib to avoid the chance of suffocation. A light, firm mattress will give your baby a great night's sleep, while a laminated vinyl mattress cover will protect against late-night accidents.

Refine By
Serta Crib Mattresses
$80.15

Serta's Nightstar Deluxe Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress is designed to comfortably deliver the support babies need and deserve. It...s features include a waterproof and stain-resistant vinyl cover, natural fire protection, an ortho-insulated layer for a... read more

Secure Beginnings
$419.99

The SafeSleep Breathable Crib Mattress from Secure Beginnings is a scientifically proven safer mattress that allows an infant who ...rolls face down to breathe normally. Passive airflow design also reduces overheating for a more comfortable sleep for baby. read more

Secure Beginnings
$419.99

The SafeSleep Breathable Crib Mattress from Secure Beginnings is a scientifically proven safer mattress that allows an infant who ...rolls face down to breathe normally. Passive airflow design also reduces overheating for a more comfortable sleep for baby. read more

Secure Beginnings
$517.95

The SafeSleep Breathable Crib Mattress from Secure Beginnings is a scientifically proven safer mattress that allows an infant who ...rolls face down to breathe normally. Passive airflow design also reduces overheating for a more comfortable sleep for... read more

Secure Beginnings
$495.57

Say goodbye to unsafe bedding and crib mattresses. The SafeSleep Eco-friendly Crib Mattress allows baby to breathe freely through ...the unit and eliminates the need for potentially harmful bumpers, pads and sheets. Based on a CPSC-approved testing lab's... read more

Secure Beginnings
$450.83

Say goodbye to unsafe bedding and crib mattresses. The SafeSleep Breathable Crib Mattress allows baby to breathe freely through th...e mattress and eliminates the need for potentially harmful bumpers, pads and sheets. Based on a CPSC-approved testing... read more

Simmons Kids
$133.99

Serta's Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress achieves a strong, stable and safe sleep surface that's made especially for... your growing baby. Built with 120 heavy-duty innerspring coils for long-lasting firmness, air vents to keep it fresh,...... read more

Simmons Kids
$83.99

Serta's Nightstar™ Glow Crib and Toddler Mattress is designed with all the features you'd hope to find in your child's first mattr...ess: a waterproof and stain resistant vinyl cover, cloth binding for long-lasting durability, plus a lightweight... read more

Newton
$79.99

The Newton Baby Wovenaire Crib Mattress Replacement Cover is crafted of 2 layers of 3 dimensional spacer material. Quilted togethe...r to create tiny pillows of air, this 100% polyester cover will provide your baby with top comfort. read more

Playkids
$31.90

Does your baby bassinet need a mattress replacement? Finally, baby can rest comfortably in a bassinet, well supported by our numbe...r one quality mattress! Crafted of 2in thick foam and covered in a tear resistant and water resistant vinyl.This pristine... read more

Dorel Home Furnishings
$91.16

Women across America voted and Safety 1st earned the title of America's Most Recommended brand for Crib & Toddler Mattress. Your n...ew arrival will sleep like a baby every night thanks to the Safety 1st Classic 112 crib and toddler bed mattress, made... read more

Secure Beginnings
$298.26

Say goodbye to unsafe bedding and crib mattresses. The Mini Breathable Crib Mattress allows baby to breathe freely through the mat...tress and eliminates the need for potentially harmful bumpers, pads and sheets. Based on a CPSC-approved testing lab's... read more

Westwood Design
$59.99

Let all your worries drift away as your baby drifts into dreamland on the Westwood Design Imagio Classic Foam Crib Mattress. This ...mattress is made of self-expanding foam core for a firm and breathable cushion in your child's crib. The crib mattress has... read more

Sealy
$112.99

Features: Exclusive POSTURETECH Coil System offers 220 POSTURETECH coils that sense your baby's movement, then respond wiith incre...asing support - Correct Support! All-Around Heavy Gauge Steel Border Rods Maximize Side, Corner and Edge Firmness Steel... read more

My First
$95.99

The My First Crib Mattress provides a supportive and comfortable sleep surface for your growing baby. Made of high density polyure...thane memory foam, the mattress offers extra firm support and features a waterproof cover and square corners for a snug fit. read more

Simmons Kids
$183.15

The Beautyrest Platinum Nightfall Crib and Toddler Mattress from Simmons Kids provides your child an outstanding sleep experience ...with its expert craftsmanship, innovative design and superior style. Built to fit both standard size cribs and toddler... read more

Childcraft
$105.78

This Child Craft 88-coil innerspring crib mattress provides needed support for your new baby while providing a comfortable sleepin...g surface. Its heavy vinyl cover wipes clean with soap and water and is antibacterial. Size: Crib/Toddler Bed. Color:... read more

Serta
$201.78

Serta's iComfort Mirage Firm Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress has a balanced mix of features that will help your child sleep soundly.... At the core of the mattress supportive soy enhanced foam provides firm comfort while the clearly labeled infant and... read more

Foundations
$74.99

Foundations Professional Series 4 Innerspring Compact Crib Mattress: Fits Foundations 13 series compact size cribs 4in steel inner...spring construction Antimicrobial vinyl provides superior hygiene Hypoallergenic and phthalate-free Dimensions: 38inL x... read more

Colgate
$299.99

Colgate Crib Mattress is widely regarded as the inventor of the modern crib mattress and once again they have proven to be categor...y innovators with the launch of their revolutionary Nuzzle Snuze line made from a 100% recyclable material called... read more

Colgate
$309.99

EC615F Features: -Bamboo yarn sleep surface cloth cover with waterproof backing; ecologically friendlier hypo-allergenic polyureth...ane foam made with plant oils; ecologically friendlier hypo-allergenic viscoelastic memory foam made with plant... read more

Sealy
$73.38

The Sealy Ortho Rest Crib Mattress is a perfect addition to complete the looks of your nursery. This toddler bed mattress comes wi...th 150 heavy gauge interwoven steel coils for a firm foundation. This gives your baby a firm support to have an... Color:... read more

Naturepedic
$399.00

For updated, accurate country of origin data, it is recommended that you rely on product packaging or manufacturer information. Pr...emium Organic Cotton Waterproof Cover - Features a luxurious organic cotton fabric with an easy-to-clean food grade 100%... read more

L.A. Baby
$89.45

Low price, durability, and comfort can go hand in hand. All of our mattresses are a testament to this truth. Our High Density Cert...iPUR-US certified soy foam core works together with a knitted cotton layer to provide support and comfort to your baby,... read more

Kolcraft
$45.02

Your baby will sleep well, upon the Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 80 Crib Mattress. And you'll rest well, too, knowing that this... mattress is built for safety and comfort. The entire mattress is phthalate and flammability compliant, and does not... read more

Colgate Mattress
$295.46

For updated, accurate country of origin data, it is recommended that you rely on product packaging or manufacturer information. Pr...ovides support to infants. Natural and renewable cotton batting top cushioning layer for comfort and longevity. Certified... read more

Colgate
$29.99

Your baby will love sleeping on the soft and comfortable Colgate Bassinet Oval Mattress - White. Designed to fit most brands and m...odels of bassinets, this bassinet mattress can be used on both sides. Its white quilted, waterproof, and tear-resistant... read more

Serta
$120.00

A SUPER firm sleeping surface ensures restful sleep for your little bundle of joy. The Serta Tranquility Super Firm crib mattress ...features SUPER firm, balanced support throughout with heavy gauge coils, corner supports and full perimeter border wire.... read more

Serta
$109.99

The Serta Tranquility Extra Firm Crib Mattress provides an EXTRA firm sleeping surface will provide peaceful sleep for your baby. ...The Serta Tranquility Extra Firm crib mattress features EXTRA firm, balanced support throughout with heavy gauge coils and... read more

Foundations
$48.51

Foundations is the foremost supplier of cribs to child care centers and hotels in the US. More major hotel chains and child care c...hains specify Foundations cribs than any other brand of cribs. We focus our product development on high use commercial... read more

Simmons Kids
$101.99

Serta Nightstar Deluxe Crib Mattress in Beige Age Group: Infant.

Serta
$110.99

Your sleepy baby will dream the night away atop this firm Serta crib mattress. Its heavy-duty coils add extra comfort, while the s...tain-resistant, waterproof vinyl cover takes the hassle out of nighttime accidents. GreenGuard Gold certified low chemical... read more

Dream On Me
$26.99

Provide the utmost comfort for your newborn with the Dream On Me 2 in. Foam Cradle Mattress. This waterproof mattress features hyp...oallergenic and antibacterial qualities that aid in the prevention of mold, mildew, and odor. This mattress easily wipes... read more

Colgate Mattress
$159.99

Only at buybuyBaby. Ideal for infants and toddlers, this non-allergenic, dual firmness 5" foam mattress has a firm side that provi...des the support for infants that medical experts recommend and a less firm side for toddler comfort. read more

Colgate Mattress
$229.99

Ideal for infants and toddlers, this non-allergenic, dual firmness mattress has a firmer side that uses the Classica II foam for i...nfants, while the toddler side uses viscoelastic memory foam for a more comfortable, more sound, longer rest. read more

Moonlight Slumber
$189.99

Ensure your child sleeps soundly with the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer dual firmness foam crib mattress. This crib mattress of...fers excellent protection and comfort for your child. read more

Moonlight Slumber
$35.99

Your baby is practically assured of sweet dreams when he sleeps on the Moonlight Slumber Starlight Support rounded corner bassinet... mattress. Expect the best from the Moonlight Slumber bassinet mattress. read more

Colgate
$349.99

Your little one will sleep well with the Monarch II Deluxe 2-Stage Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress. This mattress fits all standard ...American cribs and toddler beds so the mattress can grow with your child, and features an easy clean vinyl cover. read more

Colgate Mattress
$119.99

This crib mattress has a lightweight foam construction that offers the ultimate in comfort. The waterproof outside cover protects ...against moisture and spills. read more

Colgate Mattress
$259.99

The deluxe spring unit of this mattress has six types of extra thick coils for an even, comfortable rest: 105 thick 12.5 and 13.5 ...gauge tempered steel coils and extra thick 6.0 gauge steel border rods for extra edge support, firmness, and durability. read more

Colgate Mattress
$119.99

Orthopedic type innerspring crib mattress has reinforced edge support and firm, even surface support from 96 thick coils and 9.0-g...auge border rods. read more

Foundations
$84.99

The Professional Series™ 4" Compact-Size Innerspring Crib Mattress from Foundations® offers the hygiene and durability previously ...found only in hospital grade mattresses. read more

Colgate Mattress
$99.99

This light weight crib mattress delivers comfort with a 5" thickness, and fits all standard cribs and toddler beds. The double lam...inated, reinforced, anti-dust mite vinyl cover easily wipes clean with a damp cloth and mild soap. read more

Colgate Mattress
$299.99

This extra high quality dual firmness innerspring crib mattress for infants and toddlers has dense, non-allergenic firm foam on th...e firmest side for extra support and convoluted eggcrate type foam on the less firm side for extra comfort. read more

Moonlight Slumber
$317.99

The Moonlight Slumber Innerspring crib mattress offers a safe and durable option for discerning parents.

Colgate Mattress
$249.99

The innovative Colgate Breathe-Flex 2-Stage Crib Mattress features coils made of food-grade polyethylene foam that offer superior ...air circulation and a lightweight design. Flip the mattress to the toddler side for continued use in the toddler years. read more

Naturepedic
$299.99

The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic 252 offers premium support combined with a more natural, healthy and comfortable sleep envi...ronment. With 252 coils, edge support, organic cotton throughout, and a firm easy-to-clean non-toxic waterproof surface,... read more

Colgate Mattress
$349.99

Ideal for infants and toddlers, this non-allergenic, Monarch Dual Firmness Innerspring Crib Mattress has a firm side for supportin...g infants and a less firm side with viscoelastic memory foam for toddlers. read more

Simmons
$149.99

Give your growing baby the sleep comfort they need with the Serta Tranquility™ Eco Firm Crib & Toddler Mattress. With a dual-sided... construction, this versatile mattress features a firm side for infancy, and a comfortable cotton side for toddlerhood. read more

View wishlist Continue shopping