Christmas Is Politically Incorrect, Yet More Preferred And Profitable

2 years.

Dear Jack,

Here in this quick snapshot, you sit proudly next to our humble $20 Christmas tree from Kroger…or should I say, our “family tree?”

It’s apparently politically incorrect to say “Merry Christmas” as opposed to “Happy Holidays.” However, that doesn’t mean it necessarily is the smarter thing to do, as explained in this article from Forbes contributor Paul Jankowski:

“Several retail giants learned this the hard way when they began taking the word Christmas out of their November and December advertising campaigns in an attempt to be politically correct. Lowe’s, Home Depot, Sears, Walmart, TargetBest Buy, and GAP have all felt the wrath of believers when they abandoned Christmas for more generic well wishes like ‘happy holidays’ and Lowe’s infamous ‘family tree.’ The result: a slew of negative media coverage and consumer push-back.”

“Merry Christmas” not only is the smarter choice for retailers, but it is also the choice phrase of the majority:

A recent article in The Washington Examiner, based on the most recent Rasmussen Reports survey, announces that currently 68% of people polled prefer “Merry Christmas” over the 23% who prefer “Happy Holidays.”

So it should be no surprise that a 2012 poll by The Pew Forum On Religion & Public Life indicates that 73% of Americans identify with Christianity.

Bottom line: The majority supports Christmas. So why is this an issue?

Let’s find out by hearing from the minority…

I was referred to a well-written article by Sam Killerman of the blog It’s Pronounced Metrosexual. His article “30+ Examples Of Christian Privilege” helped me understand the “Happy Holidays” crowd a bit better.

This particular example of Christian privilege opened my eyes: ” [As a Christian] you aren’t pressured to celebrate holidays from another faith that may conflict with your religious values.”

As much as I personally support the separation of church and state, I can’t deny the fact that Christmas is a Federal holiday.

Of course, there’s really no way around this. If 73% of the work force requested to be off the same day in every office and plant, it would be an issue every year.

So the most practical thing to do is make the explicitly Christian holiday an official paid holiday.

But going back to the minority who prefer “Happy Holidays,” it seems something they all have in common with each other is they feel marginalized and/or intimidated by the majority.

Likewise, it seems that the “Merry Christmas” folks also feel marginalized and/or intimidated by the minority.

By the time you are old enough to read this letter, I don’t know that this will be that big of a deal anymore.

My hope is that the American population will be less polarized- that the Republicans and the Democrats won’t brand each other as completely irrational and/or evil and actually learn to compromise instead of zealously endorsing their own political party.

I can’t change how everyone else views each other, but I can influence how you see everyone else. As your parent, I will be deliberately teaching you that no group is completely irrational and/or evil, whether they’re for or against gay marriage, abortion, legalizing marijuana, nationalized health care, or using the term “Merry Christmas.”

We can’t worry about what they think, anyway. We’ve got each other, kid. That’s all I care about.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!





Add a Comment
Back To The Dadabase
  1. by Kim

    On December 12, 2012 at 9:33 pm

    As far as Christmas goes, everyone feels pressured. Its what retailers want.

    I also know several non-christians that got exceptionally torked to have their religion lumped together with every thing else in the happy holidays issue. The retailers are pushing Christmas, period. Hanukkah and Kwanzaa (and others I`m afraid to try and spell) are not what they are making money off of. The smart retailers started carrying merchandise catering to the minority, and just say Merry Christmas. I`ve even been greeted with `Have a good Kwanzaa!` a time or two. The stores that let the employees wish the holiday they celebrate get much more business and a reputation for being conciderate.

  2. by Nick Shell

    On December 12, 2012 at 9:55 pm


    I love your comment! Very insightful! I never thought about non-Christians’ holiday getting lumped in with Christmas and that not being cool with them. Good call.

  3. by Luca

    On December 15, 2012 at 10:29 am

    If a company is going to push all Christmas decorations etc, put all sales in the few days before Christmas and the day after etc, saying “Happy Holidays” is hypocritical.

    But on the flip side there are companies like Apple that do non religious icon based decorations (okay yeah their ‘holiday uniform’ are red shirts but that color stands out in a crowd way more than their standard blue), don’t do special sales and such. For them saying “Happy Holidays” doesn’t come off as being hypocritics and I, as a non Christian, appreciate that they are trying to be more neutral and fair