When I was pregnant, my big complaint was insomnia, which began in my second trimester and only got worse.
But even tougher was the reaction I got every time I mentioned my insomnia to anyone: "Just wait until the baby arrives."
At the time, I laughed off the warning. But when my beautiful daughter, Ella, finally arrived -- and my body was finally willing to grant me the sleep I craved -- I really learned what it meant to be sleep deprived. Waking every hour or two to nurse or change Ella left me exhausted, both physically and mentally. While nursing, Ella would peacefully fall asleep, only to start screaming the second her little body touched the bassinet. But if my husband, Patrick, or I slid her between us in bed instead, she'd stay asleep. We tossed out all thoughts of establishing good sleep habits early on, in favor of getting a few hours of uninterrupted zzz's.
Flash forward to now, when Ella is 15 months old and still sleeping with us every night. We had tried Ferberizing when she was 4 months and 8 months old. Ferber advocates that you teach your baby to put herself to sleep by letting her cry it out. Patrick was willing to tough this out, but I always insisted we give up after a few days. My reasons were practical -- we live in New York City, so her screaming kept up not only us but also all of our neighbors -- as well as emotional. I just couldn't bear to listen to my baby cry.
So why try again? For starters, whoever coined the expression "sleeping like a baby" didn't know what he was talking about. Babies flail about in their sleep, so Patrick and I kept waking up with a fist or foot in our faces. And our bed seemed to grow smaller as Ella grew bigger. None of us were getting enough sleep, so I swore to my husband that I would faithfully heed Ferber's advice. What follows is my night-by-night account of our sleep-training days.
What do you think of this story? Tell Us.
Please confirm your comment by answering the question below and clicking "Submit Comment."
My daughter is 13 months old and has slept in our bed from day one. We get great sleep but we are missing the intimacy our relationship used to have. So we're planning on beginning the process of weaning her from our bed starting next week. Every other parent and doctor I've spoken too assures me that by 12 months old a baby know she can trust you and doesn't "unlearn" that trust just because you make her sleep alone.
8/3/2011 07:18:04 AM Report AbuseMy little one is 14months,I but him to bed at 8 know problem falling a sleep but around 2-3 o clock he will wake up screaming, a few time we will put him in bed with us but then he does sleep. We use to give him his pacifier which soothed him but now for the last month we took pacifier away his fine with that he does wan't it but like i said around 2 he wakes up screaming. I don't know anymore what is wrong and what to do?
6/7/2011 09:08:00 AM Report AbuseI would NEVER do this to my baby. I love him too much. I'm not too lazy to care and comfort him the way he should be. A baby should be loved not neglected. All you have to do is go in and pat the back and talk to the child. I did this around age 1 with my other two kids and had them sleeping in their own beds without fuss in about 3 days. I would stand right outside their door and go in after about 20 seconds if they started fussing. I NEVER let them cry.
10/8/2010 01:31:59 PM Report AbuseHI I READ YOUR STORY AND I THINK THAT THE METHOD YOU USE IS REALLY GOOD AND IT SEEMS THAT IT REALLY WORKED OUT, IS A REALLY GOOD SUGGESTION FOR MOTHERS THAT ARE IN THE SAME SITUATION.
9/4/2010 10:27:06 PM Report AbuseIs 3 months too early??
6/13/2010 01:39:48 PM Report AbuseThats better than its been in months...so I see success already
5/8/2010 12:45:00 PM Report AbuseIm in the process of doing this now! Yesterday was our first day and we started with naptime. It's the hardest thing Ive ever done and I feel awful doing it but I know that falling asleep on her own is important for her and she will need this skill for the rest of her life. One of my friends said that teaching your child how to sleep on their own is like giving them a gift. I agree. Im only on day two but Lilah slept last night from 6-11 cried for an hour and then slept from 12- almost 6.
5/8/2010 12:44:37 PM Report AbuseMy daughter Hanna is 17 months and only SOMETIMES sleeps through the night!! She always starts out in her crib but many nights ends up in our bed. I seem to be getting more sleep than i used to!!
4/12/2010 05:07:35 PM Report Abusemy baby is three months and still dont sleep throw the night
4/7/2010 08:15:24 PM Report AbuseWow I am ready to go back to my bed. My daughter starts out i her crib then somehow she feels I am not there and begins to scream. I pick her up breastfeed her and lay her beside me in her twin bed with intentions of putting her back in her crib, but I fell asleep. This a every night thing now. How do I break it?
3/31/2010 09:49:18 PM Report AbuseMy little bundal of joy is one of those power nappers! from 11:30 pm till 4am she sleeps on and off she really dosn't want anything just a sip of the bottle and a kiss but I feel like I never get any sleep! Could she be having baby nightmares? Has anyone else had this problem because this is my fifth child and I never had this problem before.
3/29/2010 10:47:53 AM Report Abuseur story gives me hope!!! im goinn through sleep trainning with my son he is 9 months!
3/16/2010 12:31:31 PM Report AbuseI understand fully my daughter slept with us untill 16mnths getting her to sleep on her own was so hard we tried leaving her to cry going in every 5min just pat her and NOT take her out the crib then every 10 min. The reason for the crying is that they know when they cry you come in so if you show her that you don't run to her everytime she cries TRUST me she stop . It took 3nights now she sleeps so peacefully alnight
2/26/2010 10:19:06 AM Report AbuseTiffany, you clearly need to read "Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child" to understand the importance of sleep. You cannot judge someone unless you walk in his or her shoes. I commend the author on her successful attempt to help her child learn to fall asleep on her own. She has taught her child a valuable lesson. And there is NO evidence letting a baby "cry it out" does psychological harm. Please do your research before stating such a hurtful statement.
12/28/2009 05:03:38 PM Report AbuseI dont agree with u tiffanycmyers its not a very good idea to let your infant sleep with u at night because they will get in the habit of sleeping with u and it will be hard to break the habit i learned the hard way with my oldest child he was 4 yrs old and trying to sleep with mommy and i wouldnt have it he is a big boy i finally got him sleeping in his own bed
11/26/2009 05:18:22 AM Report AbuseWell said tiffanycmyers
11/18/2009 07:28:34 PM Report AbuseMy son sleeps in his crib and has since he was 2 months old. Every night I rock him to sleep and then place him in his crib. Sometimes he sleeps through the night but most the time he cries for a second and I give him his binky asap and he goes back to bed. A few times he will scream and I will have to rock him again. I think Methods of putting your child to sleep is different for each parent and you have to know your limitations and your babies. There is no right or wrong.
11/18/2009 02:08:05 PM Report AbuseWOW TO THE COMMENT BEFORE ME. ARE THEY SERIOUS? BUT ANY WAY DO YOU THINK THIS COULD BE DONE OR WOULD I BE A BAD PARENT IF I DID THIS TO MY CHILD SHE IS 5 MTHS OLD I FEEL ALL THE THINGS YOU FELT AS A MOM PLEASE RESPOND ITS JUST AN OPIONION THANKS :)
11/12/2009 12:08:59 AM Report AbuseHave you never heard of the damage this does to your infant? She's learning she cannot trust you to comfort her and this will translate into an adult with trust issues- all because you are whining that you can't sleep. The baby years only last a short few and she will never wish to be in your bed in the years to come. Stop forcing your child to become an adult when all she wants is the comfort of her mother's arms.
11/4/2009 12:23:33 PM Report Abuse