Mom-Tested Baby Slings & Carriers

We put 15 carriers and slings to the test. Check out what our mommy testers had to say, and find the one that's right for your bambino.
  • Share
  • Print Print
  • Comment Comments (4)

Maya Wrap
1 of 16
Next
Maya Wrap Lightly Padded Sling

You know that a baby carrier is a new-mom must-have, with magical baby-soothing powers and the ability to give you your hands back. (Finally!) But there are so many to choose from -- which one should you pick?


We looked at virtually every carrier on the market before we narrowed the field to 15 to test. We asked real moms to put them through the paces -- nursing, taking walks, even unloading the dishwasher (if they felt it was safe). Here's what worked and what didn't:


What It Is: A long piece of fabric that's threaded through rings to make a pouch for baby.

Recommended Weight Range: Up to 35 pounds

Price: $55.95

Why We Love It: There's extra padding on the shoulder (where you need it most) and we like the built-in pocket that just fits your keys and a few bucks for those quick trips out.

One Thing We'd Change: Both of our testers thought this sling had just too much fabric and in some positions, was too long. It's available in four sizes, but the ranges are pretty broad: Small fits people under 5'2", Medium fits 5'2" to 5'9", Large is over 5'9", and Extra Large fits a large frame.

What the Real Moms Say:

"I could easily bend down to help one of my toddlers, but I wouldn't wear this sling while unloading dishes or doing laundry -- it didn't feel that secure. I love the video demonstrations on the Maya Wrap web site, and also like that the sling goes up to her shoulder blades and keeps her snug against me." -- Cindy (shown), Minneapolis, Minnesota; mom to Julia, 9 months, 17 pounds


"I thought the Maya Wrap was beautiful, and I loved the idea of carrying my baby in it, but it didn't work at all for Kara. It doesn't allow any room for movement, and she'd scream until I took her out. The fabric is gorgeous and machine washable, but with a baby as "healthy" (approximately 16 pounds) as mine, I wouldn't feel completely comfortable wearing it without also supporting her with my arm." -- Bree, Indianapolis, Indiana; mom to Kara, 3 months, 16 pounds

Maya Wrap, Lightly Padded Sling, $66, available at www.mayawrap.com

Read the CPSC's Warnings About Baby Slings

What do you think of this story?  Tell Us.

1 of 16
Next
Related Links
Most infants love to be in a carrier against your ...

Parents helps you pick the best the best backpack ...

Parents Are Talking
Comments (4)
4713158514
iamacliche1 wrote:

You should review the TULA baby carrier (www.babytula.com). Easy buckles for a quick on and off, super cute prints, detachable sleep hood, ergonomic, and a super handy pocket on the waistband.

2/6/2012 09:03:10 PM Report Abuse
neanjh wrote:

I can see that this is a little old due to the dates of the comments, but I feel obligated to point out that many of these photos (including this one) show these carriers being worn incorrectly. That may be the reason some of the mothers that tried them had some of the complaints they shared. The rings on a ring sling should be up near the shoulder, and if it isn't tightened appropriately then you would feel like it's not secure enough.

8/29/2011 10:58:21 PM Report Abuse
nlabandter1 wrote:

Did you by any chance check out the "Baby K'tan" ...I think it is the best carrier. If you haven't, I would be interested to know how you rate it. Natalie

4/3/2011 11:34:23 PM Report Abuse
il0v3him wrote:

Does this work well with breastfeeding? I have a soon-to-be 3-yr-old and i know I am not always going to be able to sit down to breastfeed. I just really want a good sling that will work well with breastfeeding. I am 5'5".

7/6/2010 07:44:55 PM Report Abuse
Add your comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Please confirm your comment by answering the question below and clicking "Submit Comment."

  • Mom Finds
  • Mom Tools
  • Win
Parents Magazine on Facebook

Latest updates from Parents Network

Follow American Baby on Twitter Follow Parents on Twitter